You Be The Judge

Welcome!

You Be The Judge presents a real legal case that was presented in court and for which a jury came to a resolution. You will be provided a brief overview of the case and an opportunity to review arguments from both the plaintiff and the defense. Upon completion of the review, you will Be The Judge and provide your opinion based on the merits of the case as presented.

Please submit your email address with your vote to be notified of the actual outcome of this case. In addition, you will receive notification of the next opportunity to Be The Judge and sit in review of a new case.

To proceed, please read the overview provided below. Utilize the navigation on the right of your screen to view arguments for the plaintiff and defense, and then to cast your vote.

Overview - Estate of Mr. Bailey Johnson v Horizons Nursing Home

In 1997 and 1998, Mr. Bailey Johnson lived at Horizons Nursing Home. He was unsteady when he walked and had a history of falling while living at Horizons.

In late 1998, Mr. Johnson fell while walking to the restroom. He was taken to the Hospital and diagnosed with a hip fracture. He had hip surgery at the Hospital and was transferred back to Horizons Nursing Home.

Because he had had hip surgery, Mr. Johnson was required to stay in bed for a period of time to recuperate. As a result of being in bed for extended periods of time, he developed several bed sores, including one on his right heel. The bed sore on his heel became so infected that he had to have his right leg amputated below the knee. Mr. Johnson died shortly after the amputation.

Mr. Johnson’s family sued Horizons Nursing Home for negligence and wrongful death.